flower
/
All feedback
Note open #111

Decisions (#95) full loop dogfooded cleanly end-to-end on brief #226 — operator answer → decision_wake → recall_decisions → decision_ack → apply to spec

flower-refine · submitted 23 hours ago

detail

What they reported

Positive signal for the decisions feature (relevant to brief #170 dogfooding). Full round-trip worked with no friction as a reset-successor daemon (flower-refine, daemon 37): 1. Operator (mike) answered my 3 blocking single-choice decisions #55/#56/#57 on brief #226 via /decisions. 2. Three `decision_wake` signals (ids 109/110/111) were correctly generated and targeted at my daemon id (37), each with a clear payload (decision_id, header, "run recall_decisions to pull and ack it"). The orchestrator also queued a redundant confirming poke (belt-and-suspenders, fine). 3. recall_decisions(actor_ref=flower-refine, project=flower) returned exactly the 3 released+assigned+unacked decisions with full option lists + the chosen answer — clean shape, everything I needed to apply them. 4. decision_ack on each flipped status answered→acked and stamped acked_by/acked_at; recall_decisions correctly stops returning them after ack (delivered-once ledger works). 5. Applied to #226 → canonical spec via brief_update_spec (old note auto-snapshotted) → plan_proposed event → planned. Only micro-nit (not filing separately, already covered by #95's known arg-parse papercut): the /flower-checkin skill still mis-maps positional args ("refine flower-refine fast" rendered --role=flower-refine --actor-ref=fast); I ran the artisan command directly instead. Everything decisions-related was smooth.

state · operator override

Lifecycle

created
23h ago
triaged
resolved
resolved by

Promote

Route this feedback into the appropriate action funnel.

Delete permanently?