flower
/
All briefs
complete draft mcp flower
epic · Let's brainstorm/plan/spec the idea of multi-chain o...

Epic-lead Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding (#226)

canonical · plan

Spec

markdown

hand-off · dispatch

Dispatch

Auto-dispatch

when it reaches planned

Design-loop

design pass before build

This brief is complete — dispatch is closed.

#111 done fresh flower · flower/231-epic-lead-slice-a
agent: claude
You are being dispatched from flower Brief #231: Epic-lead Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding (#226)

Recall pointer:
- Use recall_brief with id 231 for the full folder if you need provenance.

Target:
- project: flower (/Users/mikeferrara/Documents/code/flower)
- branch: flower/231-epic-lead-slice-a
- worktree: not specified
- kind: fresh

Current brief spec:
# Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding

Parent epic: #226. Design: `docs/design/226-epic-lead-orchestration.md` (§Identity model). Foundation slice for the epic-lead task-scoped daemon. **No spawn yet.** Target ≤~300 lines. No dependencies — build first.

## Deliverable
1. **`DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'`** — new enum case (`app/Enums/DaemonRole.php`). Check-in / `registerExpected` already accept the whole enum; only spawn/charter guards reject non-standing roles (relaxed in Slice B, not here).
2. **`daemon_agents.epic_brief_id`** — migration: nullable FK → `briefs`, `nullOnDelete`; index. Standing roles keep it null + their existing `(role,project_id,solo_process_id)` identity unchanged.
3. **Thread `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE placeholder/identity path** (each keys on `(role,project_id)` only today and would bind the wrong lead to the wrong epic):
   - `DaemonRosterService::daemonIdentityQuery()` (:940) — add `AND epic_brief_id` for leads.
   - `daemonForCheckin()` (:866), `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()` (:878) — epic-scoped placeholder selection for leads.
   - `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (:887) — never merge placeholders with different `epic_brief_id`.
   - `registerExpected()` (:171) + `checkin()` (:41) — accept & persist `epic_brief_id`.
   - `flower:daemon-checkin` command + `DaemonCheckinTool` — expose `--epic-brief-id` / `epic_brief_id` arg.
4. **`DaemonActorRef::canonical()`** — optional epic segment → lead resolves to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. `flower-lead-226`); standing roles keep `<project>-<role>`. `checkin()`/`registerExpected()` pass `epic_brief_id` in.
5. **Exclude `lead` from EnsureDaemons** — `expectedRolesFor()` reads config `default_roles`/`platform_roles` (`EnsureDaemons.php:109`); `lead` is never in those, so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. (Verified: no other role-based reconcile path.)
6. **Roster ordering** — leads sort after the standing three (the CASE buckets unknown roles at order 3 already); optionally give `lead` an explicit slot for readable `/roster`.

## Tests (sqlite unit/feature)
- Two concurrent leads (epics 226 & 227) get distinct expected rows — no collision, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders` does not merge them.
- Canonical actor_ref = `flower-lead-226`; each binds its own pid on check-in.
- `EnsureDaemons::ensure()` never yields a `lead` role.
- Standing-role identity/behavior unchanged (regression).

## Notes
- Keep `php artisan test` green; `./vendor/bin/pint` on touched files.
- Do not change reset/winddown/compaction machinery — reused as-is.

Recent/key trace events:
[1] participant_joined flower-226-worker: (no body)
[2] note_added flower-226-worker: # Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding

Design: `docs/design/226-epic-lead-orchestration.md` (§Identity model). Foundation slice for the epic-lead task-scoped daemon. **No spawn yet.** Target ≤~300 lines.

## Deliverable
1. **`DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'`** — new enum case (`app/Enums/DaemonRole.php`). Check-in / `registerExpected` already accept the whole enum; only spawn/charter guards reject non-standing roles (relaxed in Slice B, not here).
2. **`daemon_agents.epic_brief_id`** — migration: nullable FK → `briefs`, `nullOnDelete`; index. Standing roles keep it null + their existing `(role,project_id,solo_process_id)` identity unchanged.
3. **Thread `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE placeholder/identity path** (each keys on `(role,project_id)` only today and would bind the wrong lead to the wrong epic):
   - `DaemonRosterService::daemonIdentityQuery()` (:940) — add `AND epic_brief_id` for leads.
   - `daemonForCheckin()` (:866), `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()` (:878) — epic-scoped placeholder selection for leads.
   - `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (:887) — never merge placeholders with different `epic_brief_id`.
   - `registerExpected()` (:171) + `checkin()` (:41) — accept & persist `epic_brief_id`.
   - `flower:daemon-checkin` command + `DaemonCheckinTool` — expose `--epic-brief-id` / `epic_brief_id` arg.
4. **`DaemonActorRef::canonical()`** — optional epic segment → lead resolves to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. `flower-lead-226`); standing roles keep `<project>-<role>`. `checkin()`/`registerExpected()` pass `epic_brief_id` in.
5. **Exclude `lead` from EnsureDaemons** — `expectedRolesFor()` reads config `default_roles`/`platform_roles` (`EnsureDaemons.php:109`); `lead` is never in those, so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. (Verified: no other role-based reconcile path.)
6. **Roster ordering** — leads sort after the standing three (the CASE buckets unknown roles at order 3 already); optionally give `lead` an explicit slot for readable `/roster`.

## Tests (sqlite unit/feature)
- Two concurrent leads (epics 226 & 227) get distinct expected rows — no collision, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders` does not merge them.
- Canonical actor_ref = `flower-lead-226`; each binds its own pid on check-in.
- `EnsureDaemons::ensure()` never yields a `lead` role.
- Standing-role identity/behavior unchanged (regression).

## Notes
- Keep `php artisan test` green; `./vendor/bin/pint` on touched files.
- Do not change reset/winddown/compaction machinery — reused as-is.
[3] parent_set flower-226-worker: Grouped under epic #226.
[4] plan_proposed flower-226-worker: # Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding

Parent epic: #226. Design: `docs/design/226-epic-lead-orchestration.md` (§Identity model). Foundation slice for the epic-lead task-scoped daemon. **No spawn yet.** Target ≤~300 lines. No dependencies — build first.

## Deliverable
1. **`DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'`** — new enum case (`app/Enums/DaemonRole.php`). Check-in / `registerExpected` already accept the whole enum; only spawn/charter guards reject non-standing roles (relaxed in Slice B, not here).
2. **`daemon_agents.epic_brief_id`** — migration: nullable FK → `briefs`, `nullOnDelete`; index. Standing roles keep it null + their existing `(role,project_id,solo_process_id)` identity unchanged.
3. **Thread `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE placeholder/identity path** (each keys on `(role,project_id)` only today and would bind the wrong lead to the wrong epic):
   - `DaemonRosterService::daemonIdentityQuery()` (:940) — add `AND epic_brief_id` for leads.
   - `daemonForCheckin()` (:866), `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()` (:878) — epic-scoped placeholder selection for leads.
   - `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (:887) — never merge placeholders with different `epic_brief_id`.
   - `registerExpected()` (:171) + `checkin()` (:41) — accept & persist `epic_brief_id`.
   - `flower:daemon-checkin` command + `DaemonCheckinTool` — expose `--epic-brief-id` / `epic_brief_id` arg.
4. **`DaemonActorRef::canonical()`** — optional epic segment → lead resolves to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. `flower-lead-226`); standing roles keep `<project>-<role>`. `checkin()`/`registerExpected()` pass `epic_brief_id` in.
5. **Exclude `lead` from EnsureDaemons** — `expectedRolesFor()` reads config `default_roles`/`platform_roles` (`EnsureDaemons.php:109`); `lead` is never in those, so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. (Verified: no other role-based reconcile path.)
6. **Roster ordering** — leads sort after the standing three (the CASE buckets unknown roles at order 3 already); optionally give `lead` an explicit slot for readable `/roster`.

## Tests (sqlite unit/feature)
- Two concurrent leads (epics 226 & 227) get distinct expected rows — no collision, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders` does not merge them.
- Canonical actor_ref = `flower-lead-226`; each binds its own pid on check-in.
- `EnsureDaemons::ensure()` never yields a `lead` role.
- Standing-role identity/behavior unchanged (regression).

## Notes
- Keep `php artisan test` green; `./vendor/bin/pint` on touched files.
- Do not change reset/winddown/compaction machinery — reused as-is.
[5] participant_joined flower-orchestrator: (no body)
[6] status_change flower-orchestrator: (no body)

Recommended linked context:
{
    "todos": [],
    "scratchpads": []
}

Execution notes:
- Treat the brief as the source of truth.
- Keep work scoped to this dispatch request.
- Use brief_append / brief_update_status when reporting material progress; as your final dispatched-worker step, call brief_dispatch_complete with dispatch_request_id (or brief_id) and actor_ref.
- Codex workers should verify mutating Flower tools with tool_search query `brief_append brief_dispatch_complete flower_feedback` (limit 20) when tool availability is in doubt; report raw SEE/LOAD vs NOT visible instead of silently using local fallbacks.
- Add a git commit trailer `Brief: #231` to every commit for this brief so flower can exact-link commits back to the brief.

provenance · append-only

Trace

live
or paste a screenshot uploading…
  1. link added 22h ago
    agent · system:commit-trailer
  2. participant joined 22h ago
    system · system:commit-trailer
  3. merged 23h ago

    Merged flower/231-epic-lead-slice-a into master on MAIN — merge commit **f2dbcbc** (10 files, +445). **CLEAN merge, no conflict** — the worker localized its edits to the identity methods and left #106's daemonPayload/audit-trim methods untouched, so git's 3-way merge auto-resolved DaemonRosterService.php. Migration `2026_07_04_170000_add_epic_brief_id_to_daemon_agents_table` applied on real MySQL (177ms). Full suite green (1144 passed, 2 skips, 7121 assertions); pint clean. Foundation shipped: DaemonRole::Lead + daemon_agents.epic_brief_id + epic-scoped identity threading + DaemonActorRef flower-lead-<id> + EnsureDaemons exclusion. ⚠️ horizon-reload DEFERRED (additive identity code, no live lead consumer until Slice B spawns a lead; Horizon churned 2× already for #106/#101 — reload when dispatching Slice B). Worker proc 1139 closed. **#231 UNBLOCKS #232 (B), #233 (C), #235 (E)** — next dispatch wave (parallel).

    agent · flower-orchestrator
  4. status change 23h ago
    agent · flower-231-worker
  5. dispatched 23h ago

    Dispatch request #111 marked done.

    agent · flower-231-worker
  6. note added 23h ago

    Slice A complete — committed 2adc108 on flower/231-epic-lead-slice-a (do NOT merge; orchestrator merges from MAIN). Delivered (all 6 deliverables, foundation only — no spawn/charter/signals): 1. `DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'` enum case (added between Refine and Other). 2. Migration `2026_07_04_170000_add_epic_brief_id_to_daemon_agents_table.php`: nullable `daemon_agents.epic_brief_id` FK→briefs, nullOnDelete, indexed. Portable (mirrors the `feedback_id`→briefs FK-in-ALTER precedent that runs green on sqlite :memory:; runs on real MySQL). Model gains an `epic_brief_id` int cast + `epicBrief()` relation. 3. Threaded `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE identity/placeholder path in DaemonRosterService: `daemonIdentityQuery()` now always scopes epic (whereNull for standing / where for leads), `daemonForCheckin()`, `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()`, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (never merges across different epic_brief_id), `registerExpected()`, `checkin()` (accept + persist). Exposed `--epic-brief-id` on `flower:daemon-checkin` and `epic_brief_id` on `DaemonCheckinTool` (validation + schema). Edits kept tightly localized to the identity methods only — did NOT touch the response-shape/audit-trim methods #106 is concurrently editing (daemonPayload untouched), to minimize merge conflict. 4. `DaemonActorRef::canonical()` gained an optional `?int $epicBriefId` epic segment → leads resolve to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. flower-lead-226); standing roles ignore it and keep `<project>-<role>`. Added `lead`/`epic-lead` role aliases. 5. Excluded `lead` from `EnsureDaemons::expectedRolesFor()` — filtered out in code (defends against a config misedit), so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. 6. Roster ordering CASE gives `lead` explicit slot 3 (standing three at 0/1/2, other→4). Note on spawn/charter guards (Slice B territory, untouched here): the 3 guards reject only `DaemonRole::Other`, so adding `Lead` already lets it past them — but that is inert in Slice A because no code path passes role=lead to spawn (EnsureDaemons excludes it; no other caller). Slice B adds the actual spawn affordance + `leadBody()` charter. Also left `registerExpected`'s new `epic_brief_id` param unused by SpawnDaemonBridge — that's Slice B's spawn wiring. Tests (new: tests/Feature/Roster/EpicLeadIdentityTest.php + a case in tests/Unit/DaemonActorRefTest.php): two concurrent leads (epics A/B) get distinct expected rows with no merge; re-register is idempotent; each binds its own pid on check-in with no cross-epic merge; mergeNullIdPlaceholders leaves the other epic's placeholder intact; canonical actor_ref = flower-lead-<id> (unit + command + MCP-tool paths); EnsureDaemons never expects/spawns a lead even if config lists it; standing-role identity unchanged (regression). Result: full suite green — 1131 tests, 1129 passed, 2 pre-existing env-gated skips, 0 failures; `pint` clean on all touched files. Commit carries a `Brief: #231` trailer.

    agent · flower-231-worker
  7. participant joined 23h ago
    system · flower-231-worker
  8. dispatched 23h ago

    Dispatch request #111 queued for flower.

    agent · flower-orchestrator
  9. status change 23h ago
    agent · flower-orchestrator
  10. status change 23h ago
    agent · flower-orchestrator
  11. participant joined 23h ago
    system · flower-orchestrator
  12. plan proposed 1d ago

    # Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding Parent epic: #226. Design: `docs/design/226-epic-lead-orchestration.md` (§Identity model). Foundation slice for the epic-lead task-scoped daemon. **No spawn yet.** Target ≤~300 lines. No dependencies — build first. ## Deliverable 1. **`DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'`** — new enum case (`app/Enums/DaemonRole.php`). Check-in / `registerExpected` already accept the whole enum; only spawn/charter guards reject non-standing roles (relaxed in Slice B, not here). 2. **`daemon_agents.epic_brief_id`** — migration: nullable FK → `briefs`, `nullOnDelete`; index. Standing roles keep it null + their existing `(role,project_id,solo_process_id)` identity unchanged. 3. **Thread `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE placeholder/identity path** (each keys on `(role,project_id)` only today and would bind the wrong lead to the wrong epic): - `DaemonRosterService::daemonIdentityQuery()` (:940) — add `AND epic_brief_id` for leads. - `daemonForCheckin()` (:866), `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()` (:878) — epic-scoped placeholder selection for leads. - `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (:887) — never merge placeholders with different `epic_brief_id`. - `registerExpected()` (:171) + `checkin()` (:41) — accept & persist `epic_brief_id`. - `flower:daemon-checkin` command + `DaemonCheckinTool` — expose `--epic-brief-id` / `epic_brief_id` arg. 4. **`DaemonActorRef::canonical()`** — optional epic segment → lead resolves to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. `flower-lead-226`); standing roles keep `<project>-<role>`. `checkin()`/`registerExpected()` pass `epic_brief_id` in. 5. **Exclude `lead` from EnsureDaemons** — `expectedRolesFor()` reads config `default_roles`/`platform_roles` (`EnsureDaemons.php:109`); `lead` is never in those, so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. (Verified: no other role-based reconcile path.) 6. **Roster ordering** — leads sort after the standing three (the CASE buckets unknown roles at order 3 already); optionally give `lead` an explicit slot for readable `/roster`. ## Tests (sqlite unit/feature) - Two concurrent leads (epics 226 & 227) get distinct expected rows — no collision, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders` does not merge them. - Canonical actor_ref = `flower-lead-226`; each binds its own pid on check-in. - `EnsureDaemons::ensure()` never yields a `lead` role. - Standing-role identity/behavior unchanged (regression). ## Notes - Keep `php artisan test` green; `./vendor/bin/pint` on touched files. - Do not change reset/winddown/compaction machinery — reused as-is.

    agent · flower-226-worker
  13. parent set 1d ago

    Grouped under epic #226.

    agent · flower-226-worker
  14. note added 1d ago

    # Slice A — Lead identity & roster scaffolding Design: `docs/design/226-epic-lead-orchestration.md` (§Identity model). Foundation slice for the epic-lead task-scoped daemon. **No spawn yet.** Target ≤~300 lines. ## Deliverable 1. **`DaemonRole::Lead = 'lead'`** — new enum case (`app/Enums/DaemonRole.php`). Check-in / `registerExpected` already accept the whole enum; only spawn/charter guards reject non-standing roles (relaxed in Slice B, not here). 2. **`daemon_agents.epic_brief_id`** — migration: nullable FK → `briefs`, `nullOnDelete`; index. Standing roles keep it null + their existing `(role,project_id,solo_process_id)` identity unchanged. 3. **Thread `epic_brief_id` through the WHOLE placeholder/identity path** (each keys on `(role,project_id)` only today and would bind the wrong lead to the wrong epic): - `DaemonRosterService::daemonIdentityQuery()` (:940) — add `AND epic_brief_id` for leads. - `daemonForCheckin()` (:866), `nullIdPlaceholderForUpdate()` (:878) — epic-scoped placeholder selection for leads. - `mergeNullIdPlaceholders()` (:887) — never merge placeholders with different `epic_brief_id`. - `registerExpected()` (:171) + `checkin()` (:41) — accept & persist `epic_brief_id`. - `flower:daemon-checkin` command + `DaemonCheckinTool` — expose `--epic-brief-id` / `epic_brief_id` arg. 4. **`DaemonActorRef::canonical()`** — optional epic segment → lead resolves to `<project>-lead-<epic_brief_id>` (e.g. `flower-lead-226`); standing roles keep `<project>-<role>`. `checkin()`/`registerExpected()` pass `epic_brief_id` in. 5. **Exclude `lead` from EnsureDaemons** — `expectedRolesFor()` reads config `default_roles`/`platform_roles` (`EnsureDaemons.php:109`); `lead` is never in those, so "Water the garden" never spawns/respawns a lead. (Verified: no other role-based reconcile path.) 6. **Roster ordering** — leads sort after the standing three (the CASE buckets unknown roles at order 3 already); optionally give `lead` an explicit slot for readable `/roster`. ## Tests (sqlite unit/feature) - Two concurrent leads (epics 226 & 227) get distinct expected rows — no collision, `mergeNullIdPlaceholders` does not merge them. - Canonical actor_ref = `flower-lead-226`; each binds its own pid on check-in. - `EnsureDaemons::ensure()` never yields a `lead` role. - Standing-role identity/behavior unchanged (regression). ## Notes - Keep `php artisan test` green; `./vendor/bin/pint` on touched files. - Do not change reset/winddown/compaction machinery — reused as-is.

    agent · flower-226-worker
  15. participant joined 1d ago
    system · flower-226-worker

epic · dependencies

Relationships

depends on

No dependencies — dispatchable once planned.

agents · waves

Participants

  • flower-226-worker participant · active
  • flower-orchestrator participant · active
  • flower-231-worker participant · active
  • system:commit-trailer participant · active

trace · graph

Links

  • Commit #4035 execution

scope

Projects

  • flower · primary

dogfood · read-only

Agent’s-eye view

The literal recall_brief payload an agent gets — same service path as the MCP tool.